A review of O'Maddy's Bar and Grill located at 5405 Shore Blvd S, Gulfport, FL 33707
We went on a Saturday afternoon and the place was packed. We were able to find a couple of chairs at the bar.
The beef was sliced very thin and extremely tender. From the picture, you can see it is rare-medium rare! This beef was the best so far although it was not as warm as I would have expected. Beef Score: 3 points
The bun was good. I prefer a bun with more salt and seeds than this one and for the bun to be to be toasted. I did like that the top of the bun had sprinkled salt and caraway seeds rather than the dipped in a bowl method. The top was not dipped in au jus. Bun Score: 1 point
Pickles were OK but a dill spear would have been more "Traditional" Pickle: 0 points
The horseradish was mild - so mild in fact I used the entire container on one half and never got the slightest horseradish burn. Horseradish: 0 points
The au jus was plentiful. Not too salty but clearly tasted like there was beef bouillon (or the like) in it. We have had much worse - but a few that were much better. Au Jus: 1 point
Overall Score: 5/10
Fries were better than average.
Service at the bar was ok considering the crowd and no complaints there.
Overall - we drove almost 2 hours for the sandwich and will gladly drive there again. Despite a few misfires and things that were not to my preference - I would rate this as an good BOW!
Comments